The Ugly Truth About Baby Registries


Baby registries are a lot of fun… well… they’re supposed to be. It doesn’t take much for them to quickly turn into a horrible drag. Yep. We’re going there. We’re going to talk about the ugly side… the ugly truth about baby registries.

When creating your baby registry it sure doesn’t take long to get totally lost in the sea of thousands of baby items.

What’s more, when the day of your beautiful baby shower arrives what is the most common gift you’re going to receive?

Baby clothes.

The crazy part is that most of the clothes won’t even be the ones you selected from your registry!

What happened to the baby safety items you had on your registry? Those blackout curtains? The baby bath you wanted?

Mama Fearless

The Ugly Truth About Baby Registries

This article isn’t slamming the generosity of others.

It’s incredible that we have the opportunity to create registry, have a party and then open gifts–things that belong to us that are brand new, for our baby, free premium gifts from our guests.

It’s amazing and humbling. We should be grateful to have that kind of support.

The reality, however, is that when people are buying your baby shower gift, they aren’t really interested in that set of cute blackout curtains when compared to that adorable little dress or that cute bear hat with the ears.

It’s just too tempting to buy those itty bitty socks rather than those nail clippers.

As a mama, you’re hoping you get that boon grass or the outlet safety covers.

It may happen, but it’s also likely that the “not-as-cute” items will remain on the registry list, long forgotten.

You are so grateful for all the gifts. But you’re a little disappointed that you got only about 15% of your actual items on your registry and now you’re feeling guilty for feeling disappointed.

The other reality is that when someone is buying from your registry, they’re actually supposed to take the registry bar code up to the cashier to scan it, informing the system that particular item has been purchased.

This whole process is to avoid duplicates and it rarely happens. Which means you get duplicates galore.

Those duplicates, however, are your best friend. More on that in a bit.

Mama Fearless

Tips to Avoid the Registry Frustration

The Ugly Truth About Baby Registries

This article contains affiliate links which means I’ll make a commission via your clickthrough or purchase at no extra cost to you. Read our disclosure.

Take heart. It’s alright. You’re going through a lot, so cut yourself some slack. Let’s talk about how to deal with the baby registry conundrum.

#1: Set Realistic Expectations

When you’re creating your registry, keep in mind that this is not a guarantee that you’re going to receive every item.

This is just telling everyone, “Hey! I love this! I’d love to have this for my baby!”

When your baby shower arrives, remember that a good amount of your guests probably didn’t go off of your registry and expect to open other cute things.

It’s probably best to not open gifts hoping and waiting for a particular item.

Just open each gift and appreciate it for what it is–an act of love and support from the giver.

Baby Shower Ideas During Social Distancing

#2: Have A Backup Plan

Not all items on your baby registry are prioritized the same way. There will be some you absolutely cannot live without.

If you feel that strongly about those items, make plans to purchase them yourself if you don’t get it from your baby shower.

You’ll probably get a lot of gift cards. Some may view it as less personal, while others view it as the most personal as it gives mama the freedom to buy whatever she wants.

Whether or not you agree, designate a place for those gift cards to go.

If you have a premium baby carrier in mind, have a plan for how you’ll use your gift cards and set aside some cash to buy it.

Be ready in case you don’t get that item from your registry.

Don’t bank on getting particular, super needed items from your registry without having a Plan B.

Get 5 Biblical Affirmations (7)

#3: Cash In Your Duplicate Items

It happens to us all. You’ll probably unwrap two, maybe even three or more of the same item.

Those gift-givers are probably feeling disappointed since they just watched you open that exact item once or twice before.

That is the time to smile profusely and thank them anyway, reassuring them.

Duplicate items are essentially the equivalent of gift cards or cash.

You can return the item for a refund if you have a gift receipt–or at the very least, store credit–and use it to purchase something that you need.

Pro-Tip: Most stores will give you store credit for an item, even if you don’t have a gift receipt, if the item still has the tags on it and has never been used. Be sure and explain it’s a baby shower gift.

Mama Fearless

#4: Hoard Your Gift Cards

If you get a lot of gift cards and/or duplicate gifts, you have a little nest egg to work with.

Personally, I used a few gift cards for things I needed right away and then I saved the rest.

I put them in a little envelope and hid them in a small compartment of my diaper bag.

As I need to, I use them for diapers and baby items, which keeps our monthly costs down. They’re nice to have set aside for a rainy day.

2020 Update: Those gift cards lasted me nearly a whole year!

#5: Don’t Create an Enormous Registry

The ugly truth about baby registries is that yours is going to take time, effort and energy.

If your registry is huge and the number of guests attending your baby shower is only a fraction of the amount of items you’ve registered, you probably overshot.

Yes, there are out-of-towners who will purchase things for you and have them sent but that’s not going to account for most of your gifts.

-Keep the amount of guests attending your shower in mind when you create your registry.

-Add items by amount of importance, so that the things you want the most are added first.

5 Baby Must Haves That Were Actually Must Nots

#6: Keep Your Registry Cost-Realistic

Make your life a little easier and create your registry based around items that are realistic for other people to buy.

If everything on your registry is over $150, you’re probably not going to receive a lot of items from your registry.

You can make your life and others’ lives easier by selecting essential items that are easy for any one person to purchase.

Examples of this are:

  • Bibs
  • Blankets
  • Crib accessories
  • Burp Cloths
  • Diapers
  • Wipes
  • Diaper/Rash Creams
  • Baby Soap and Toiletries
  • Car Seat Accessories
  • Home Safety Items
  • Toys and Books
  • Baby Towels and Sheets
  • Baby Clothes (in serious moderation)
  • Feeding Accessories, Dishes and Utensils
  • Baby First-Aid
  • Inexpensive Diaper Bag
  • Portable Baby Items (portable changing pad, etc.
  • Basic Baby Rocker

Other types of items that can be more costly and therefore may not be purchased are things like:

  • Baby Carrier
  • Stroller
  • Travel System
  • Crib
  • Exersaucer
  • Bouncer
  • Bassinet
  • High Chair
  • High-End Baby Rocker
  • Rocking Chair
  • Dresser
  • Other Baby Furniture
  • Name Brand Diaper Bag
  • Baby Monitor System
The Minimalist List of Newborn Essentials

The Ugly Truth About Baby Registries

While some of the second list of items will probably be purchased for you, they’ll most likely come from family and close family friends.

The upper list is likely to be purchased by your baby shower guests, coworkers and other friends and acquaintances.

Knowing what to expect and from where to expect it helps you plan and save some serious frustration.

If you know some of your immediate family is purchasing a particular item, maybe you don’t need to worry about adding it to the registry, unless they don’t live locally and are shipping your item to you.

One More Thing

Let’s just be realistic here, for a moment. You’ve probably already bought enough baby clothes on your own that were just so cute and irresistible.

You already know you’re going to get a lot more at your shower, so you probably don’t need to exert a lot of energy adding baby clothes to your registry, especially considering how fast clothes go on sale and are moved through a store.

Take that extra time to grab a nap or take a bath. You’re welcome.

6 Hospital Bag Tips

#7: Make Your Registry Easily Accessible to Out-of-Town Buyers

I learned this the hard way. I chose large chain stores for my registry and found that they are so vast and varying from city to city.

Many of my out-of-town family and friends couldn’t find the exact item sizing or color from my registry and either ended up texting me for more information or sending me an alternative gift.

Meanwhile, a close friend of mine opted for an Amazon Baby Registry and was getting boxes of her exact items left and right.

Not only could she manage her registry easily through the app and select items from all brands and stores, all gifts over a certain amount (I believe it was $25) included free shipping.

Basically, her registry was a raging success and mine was… meh… especially when it came to out-of-town shoppers.

I honestly wish I’d used an Amazon baby registry.

It would have saved so much time and frustration and given my out-of-town family a chance to easily buy and send the exact items that I ordered.

No more wondering down aisles, frowning at item codes and hassling with shipping.

Start your Amazon Baby Registry

#8: Let Yourself Be Excited About Everything You Get, Regardless of Your Registry

This is a wonderful, fun time. The best thing you can do is just relax and enjoy the moment.

If you’re Type-A, like me, you might find yourself stressing about all the gifts you receive, wondering what you’re going to do with them all.

Instead of stressing about it, choose to enjoy the fact that all these people love you and are excited with you, and took time to go out and get your baby something special.

Don’t stress about the extras and the random items and the stuff you didn’t get. It will all work out–really, it will.

You’re doing great. If you find yourself getting frustrated, just take some time away from your registry.

Do it in chunks so you’re not pushing yourself past the point of enjoying yourself.

10 Baby Items I Still Use A Year Later

One more thing

Remember to thank everyone for their gifts. They spent time and money to support your day. Regardless of whether or not it’s exactly what you wanted, it’s still a token of their efforts, and they deserve a hug for that.

Hey, Sister! I’ve got your back! Here’s a free baby shower gift list download. Forget scrambling around to find a piece of scratch paper and just print this one! You’re welcome 🙂

Keep up the good work, Mama!

The Ugly Truth About Baby Registries

Let's Be Friends! Follow me on Insta, Facebook and Pinterest!

Elizabeth Jimenez

Let's Be Friends! Follow me on Insta, Facebook and Pinterest!

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Sorry, this content isn\'t up for grabs. Thanks anyways :)